1.116 — INVOLUNTARY MANSLAUGHTER
Violations of "Statute 1.116" results in a Class E Felony
(a) Definitions
Involuntary manslaughter is the unlawful killing of another person without malice aforethought, that occurs due to the defendant’s recklessness, criminal negligence, or the commission of an unlawful act that is not inherently dangerous to human life.
In simpler terms, the death was not intended — but happened because the defendant was acting carelessly, irresponsibly, or violated the law in a non-violent way. It’s generally considered less severe than murder, but still a serious felony.
This differs from voluntary manslaughter or murder because the killing was not intentional, and there was no extreme indifference or depraved mindset — just poor judgment or careless behavior that resulted in someone dying.
(b) Elements
To prove involuntary manslaughter, the prosecution must establish these elements beyond a reasonable doubt:
The defendant caused the death of another person.
The actions of the defendant directly or foreseeably led to the victim’s death.
The killing was unintentional and without malice aforethought.
The defendant did not mean to kill or seriously harm the victim and was not acting with a depraved or malicious intent.
The death resulted from either:
Reckless conduct: The defendant consciously disregarded a serious risk.
Criminal negligence: The defendant failed to exercise reasonable care, creating a high risk of death.
An unlawful act that wasn’t inherently dangerous: For example, a misdemeanor or minor felony like illegally handling fireworks.
The defendant’s actions were unlawful and unjustified.
There was no valid legal reason for the conduct that caused the death
(c) Defenses
Common defenses to involuntary manslaughter include:
Accident (without negligence): If the death was a true accident and not caused by reckless or negligent behavior, it may not rise to criminal manslaughter.
Lack of causation: If the prosecution can’t prove the defendant’s conduct was the actual or legal cause of death, the charge may fail.
Consent of the victim: In rare cases, if the victim knowingly consented to the risk (e.g., during risky stunts or physical competitions), it might be a mitigating factor — but this is heavily fact-dependent.
Medical or third-party cause: If someone else’s actions, or a medical error, broke the chain of causation between the defendant’s conduct and the death.
(d) Aggravating Factors
Even though involuntary manslaughter is less severe than murder, certain aggravating factors can increase punishment:
Repeat offenses: The defendant has a history of reckless or negligent conduct, especially involving harm to others.
Gross negligence or extreme recklessness: The behavior was so careless or dangerous that it almost rises to the level of depraved indifference.
Death occurred during a minor unlawful act: Even if the underlying act wasn’t violent (e.g., driving without a license, using illegal fireworks), causing a death during that act can elevate the consequences.
Victim vulnerability: If the victim was a child, elderly, or disabled individual, sentencing may be more severe.
(e) Examples
Example 1: DUI Resulting in Death A player drives while intoxicated and accidentally hits a pedestrian. They didn’t mean to kill, but driving drunk is criminally negligent, and their behavior caused a death — that’s involuntary manslaughter.
Example 2: Mishandling Fireworks A group is celebrating the 4th of July with illegal fireworks. One player lights one off in a public area, and it explodes near a bystander, causing fatal injuries. The act wasn’t meant to harm anyone, but it was unlawful and reckless, leading to a death. Involuntary manslaughter.
Example 3: Unsafe Worksite A character running a construction company ignores safety rules and fails to secure scaffolding. A worker falls and dies. The owner didn’t intend to hurt anyone, but their negligent oversight caused a death — this qualifies as involuntary manslaughter.
Example 4: Prank Gone Wrong A player tries to prank a friend by tampering with their vehicle’s brakes as a joke. The friend later crashes and dies. Even if there was no intent to harm, the reckless behavior that directly caused the death would be involuntary manslaughter.
Last updated